Friday, August 7, 2009

A critique of an open-source software critique, or why OSS can be awesome

It's been years since I've written a critique that anyone but myself has had the (perhaps unfortunate) opportunity to read, but this particular entry - http://blog.bitquabit.com/2009/06/30/one-which-i-say-open-source-software-sucks - just begged me for it.

For full disclosure - my bias here about open-source software (OSS) should be noted. I run Ubuntu on my work computer with all sorts of OSS and freeware installed (OpenOffice, the GIMP, Inkscape, FF, NXServer+NXClient, etc.). I also posses a custom-built (by me) machine with Windows 2000 Pro, MS Office, Visual Studio, and Adobe Photoshop. I do work almost entirely from my Ubuntu machine, heavily use the wonderfully free Google Docs for interaction with clients, and have not run into any problems that have hindered my productivity. I daresay that my Windows 2000 Pro machine is also very stable, and I can be just as productive on it when I work from home.

So in short, I am totally thrilled with the state of OSS; some, probably a lot of it sucks, so I just don't use it. Same reason I never bought Neverwinter Nights 2.... But I have my biases, as does everyone, and now you know them!


OK - back to the article. I'll start with the positive - there are definitely one or two sound tidbits. I certainly agree that Apple makes a product that is becoming far more desirable than the Microsoft + Dell/HP/whoever model, so long as there's enough money in the bank to afford one.

Also, I do agree with the basic premise that commodities developed without any motivation for making it good, will - in most cases - suffer from being not-good.

However, overall, the article's argument is not sound - it is not the case that open-source software programmers suffer from an inherent lack of motivation, necessarily resulting in a sucky product. Less rooted in logical critique, I also found it annoying that before presenting the primary argument, the article defames open-source software with a smattering of ad hominem attacks (more on this later). I mean, great political technique but come on, it's not like we should all try to argue the same way Fox News reports.

SO ... on the surface, a lot of the points do pass validity checks:

a. Good software is "well thought-out, and easy-to-use, and easy-to-install, and highly efficient, and bug free."
b. Open source software is "painful to use" and "incontrovertibly, a total usability clusterfuck."
c. Therefore, open source software fails to be easy-to-use, so it is not good.

OK, so now we need to know why open source software fails to be usable. Gladly, there is some language to back this up.

a. Programmers, left to their own devices, are lazy, both in terms of creating efficient software efficiently, and not wanting to do extra work that does not make their software more efficient.
b. Programmers, primarily care about creating an "underlying, beautiful implementation," and on their own are unmotivated - as it follows from a. - to make intuitive, usable UIs.
c. Companies need to make usable, bug-free software so people will buy and use it, and so less money will need to be put into maintenance.
d. A company employs these lazy programmers and uses a salary (and probably pushy managers) as motivation to create usable, bug-free software.

e. (a. and b. restated more simply) Without motivation, the programmer will develop unusable software.
f. Since a programmer who makes open-source software lacks corporate-provided motivation, and since we've already established b., he will therefore create unusable software.
g. From f. we can conclude that Open-source software is developed without proper motivation and is consequently unusable. And the suck.

I just have to question the premises a., b. and consequently f. It's hard to argue over a. as aside from just disagreeing (which I do) and being a bit offended (I'm not that lazy), neither of us has statistical proof, so I'll just leave it be. There are possibly certain truths to b., but it might moreso be that a good amount of programmers are unable to create intuitive UIs because it's hard. I don't know for sure - an HCI person might have answers.

But I can certainly attack f. by proposing alternative motivations. There are certainly other reasons a programmer would be motivated to create a great, usable UI - hubris, for example? How many cocky programmers do you know? Or perhaps they simply want to take pride in their work, and expect a windfall from the product that is not immediately monetary in nature. Maybe they'll pull a Google, release massive amounts of open-source and freely available software, and slowly gain possession of the world's information and trust until they assimilate us all into Google-Borgs. Motivation enough for ya?

So I do agree in principle to e., that an unmotivated developer would be likely to cut corners, and the end product would suffer. But an unmotivated producer of any commodity will probably develop a pretty sucky product, and it is not the case that all open-source software suffers from an implicit lack of motivation. So throwing the baby out with the bathwater because it's not immediately monetizable is just short-sighted.


OK - now for some more fun, let's pick through all of the slander in the opening argument and try to find some meat:

a. The means of business entities with successful ends infers the "goodness" of the mean.
b. Open source software is not used by successful business entities - that "I can point to" - as a means to their end.
c. Therefore, open source software lacks "goodness".

Phew - who sees validity or non-questionable premises in that?

It does not follow that if a business is successful and uses product X, that a business that uses product Y will not be successful. If there was some data presented that showed the statistical significance of unsuccessful companies running on open-source software vs. successful companies running closed-source software, perhaps this would be acceptable. Instead, the validity of the argument simply runs out of steam after "I don't know of any successful companies that use open-source software."


OK so this wasn't a ridiculously rigorous academic analysis but I think I hit a few good points, and if I missed something by all means, critique me! And if you made it all the way down here, thanks for getting through it, and be sure to let me know what you think.

15 comments:

boston web development said...

Thanks for your ideas on design web applications and development. It would be great to create a website with a good flow of traffic caused by a great web design.

annaharris said...

There are lots of the points for Open source software and it is painful to use, beautiful implementation, and on their own is unmotivated website.

blog said...

I truly like to reading your post. Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a nice information. I'll definitely add this great post in my article section.
Small business web design

Anonymous said...

boot logon software http://buyoem.co.uk/it/manufacturer-3/Adobe media authoring software for mac [url=http://buyoem.co.uk/product-31551/Media-Catalog-4-3-MAC]gps palm free software downloads[/url] sublimnal messaging software
[url=http://buyoem.co.uk/product-36830/IBM-SPSS-Text-Analytics-for-Surveys-4-0-x64]IBM SPSS Text Analytics for Surveys 4.0 x64 - Software Store[/url] best parental control software low overhead
[url=http://buyoem.co.uk/de/category-100-108/Office-Tools?page=2][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/5.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

I аlways ѕрent my half an houг to reаd this weblog's content everyday along with a cup of coffee.

My web blog - Whitianga Beachside Accommodation

Anonymous said...

І'm amazed, I must say. Rarely do I encounter a blog that's both еducаtiνe anԁ intеreѕting,
and ωіthout a doubt, you have hit the
nаil оn the head. The problem iѕ
something too few men and ωοmеn аre sρeakіng intelligеntly about.

I am veгy happy I came across thіs ԁurіng my sеaгсh for something regaгding
this.

my web blog ... twitting hotels & Travel

Anonymous said...

[url=http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/pulmicort.htm][img]http://onlinemedistore.com/4.jpg[/img][/url]
pharmacy poster http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/apcalis-oral-jelly.htm how to design a pharmacy and photos [url=http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/accupril.htm]drugs table student pharmacy[/url]
online pharmacy 10mg percocet http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/elavil.htm td qd pharmacy terminology [url=http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/gift-kamagra-jelly.htm]gift kamagra jelly[/url]
green pharmacy list of cures http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/catalogue/r.htm appleton and lange review of pharmacy [url=http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/citalopram.htm]community pharmacy madison wi[/url]
oxymorphone no prescription online pharmacy http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/cytoxan.htm positive aspects of critical care pharmacy [url=http://certifiedpharmacy.co.uk/products/aldactone.htm]aldactone[/url]

hanry gill said...

I Like these line of your article So in short, I am totally thrilled with the state of OSS; some, probably a lot of it sucks, so I just don't use it. Same reason I never bought Neverwinter Nights 2.... But I have my biases, as does everyone, and now you know them!
web application development

Anonymous said...

Hello, just wanteԁ to say, I loved this blog pоst.
It was practical. Keep on pοsting!

my blog рοst - Strategy Your current Searching Remain in Dubai Hotels Close to Searching Middle

Anonymous said...

Hi there fгiends, good post and fastidious uгgіng commеnted
аt this рlaсe, I am rеallу enјoying by
thesе.

Herе is my blog :: Lower Price Hotels Record -- Compare Accommodations Rates

Anonymous said...

This artіcle prοvіdes clear idea for the nеw users of blogging,
that really hoω to do blоgging and ѕіte-building.


Fеel frеe to surf to mу wеbѕite .
.. Resort Price tag Assessment As opposed to Standard Vacation Look for Sites -- Resorts Discount rates

Anonymous said...

The articleice Machines introduces:This article about How To Buy Commercial Ice Machines For Restaurant,With the introduction of cutting edge and innovative technologies, a commercial ice machine is no longer a bulky device producing insanitation, consuming a lot ...

If you need more ice Machines infomation about How To Buy Commercial Ice Machines For Restaurant, Click here to find.

With the introduction of cutting ice Machines edge and innovative technologies, a commercial ice machine is no longer a bulky device producing insanitation, consuming a lot of energy, making noise, and taking a lot of time to make the needed supply of ice. As a result of high end technologies, commercial ice machines are able to achieve “being green” the highest levels of energy and water conservation. Now a commercial ice machine can easily produce from 65 pounds to 2,000 pounds of ice cubes in a day. You can find varied shapes of ice cubes such as dice, half dice, octagon, crushed, nugget, and flake.

Commercial ice machines are the standalone units,ice Machines designed to produce large quantities of ice for various commercial purposes. Once installed, these commercial ice makers are pretty automatic and do not need much attention from you or your staff. These factory-made machines consist of a condensing unit and ice-making section that operates as an integrated unit to make ice, an ice bin or a storage unit to store the created ice and a dispensing unit to dispense the ice out of the machine. Many automatic ice machines use moving water to create an improved quality of ice cubes. They work on the principle of “faster the water moves the better the ice quality becomes”. In this process, the air and un-dissolved solids get washed away. This results in pure and clear ice production.

Large amounts of ice are demanded for various purposes in many ice Machines commercial entities such as Restaurants, Bars, Ice Cream Parlors, Bakeries, Country Clubs and Golf Courses. A commercial ice machine is the perfect choice for such places as the large quantity of ice also needs to be a certain quality as well. Automatic commercial ice machines will make plenty of ice of equal size in a short span of time. All you need to do is just start the machine and set the required functions, and leave the rest up to the machine. You will get good quantity of quality ice in a short amount of time. In addition, many commercial ice machines come with a self cleaning function. This will help maintain the quality and quantity if the produced ice while decreasing the time that you and or your staff must spend with the machine.

Keep in mind that there are two varieties of ice machines: air cooled and waterice Machines cooled. Air cooled ice machines use air to disperse the heat, whereas water cooled ice machine uses water to do the same function. Air cooled ice machines use more energy and also are much noisier than water cooled ice machines. However, they are more affordable than water cooled ice machines.

An assorted collection of wonderful, fast and energy efficient commercial ice makers are readilyice Machines available in the market. Various renowned and reliable manufacturers have come up with their unique range of these amazing machines. Numerous models that create different types and sizes of ice are available in the local and online market. A competitive urge of creating more efficient and cost effective ice machines, has left the customers and consumers with a distinctive variety of these units in which to choose.

Nicole Thomas said...

I don't even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I do not know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you aren't already ;)
Web development Indore

aparna john said...

Hi,Type of Web Design Cochin can be accomplished with just about any type of web page design program.Thanks....

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.